• Skip to main content
  • Skip to after header navigation
  • Skip to site footer
My Durban

My Durban

Durban News, Business, Accommodation, Directory

  • Accommodation
    • Showcase your accommodation
    • Beachfront
    • Glenwood
    • Yacht
  • Events
  • Submit News FREE
  • News

When neighbourly conduct becomes a nuisance

18 April 2023 by Alan

With many South Africans moving their workplaces to their homes in the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic, the influence of one’s neighbours on our daily lives has become more impactful than ever before. Recently the Supreme Court of Appeal judgement of Madrasah Taleemuddeen Islamic Institute v Ellaurie and Another 2023 (2) SA 143 (SCA) (hereafter the Ellaurie-case), has once again clearly set out how the court can restrict the use and enjoyment of one’s property so as to not be a nuisance that causes unreasonable interference in one’s neighbourhood after it set aside and replaced the judgement made by the KwaZulu-Natal Division of the High Court.

It is well established that a person’s right to the use and enjoyment of their property is one of the strongest rights you can have, however this is not an unlimited right. A person is expected to endure reasonable limitations. When these limitations become unreasonable, it can however constitute a nuisance. The Ellaurie-case explained this principle and gave considerable clarity regarding what can be considered an unreasonable interference.
In this case Mister Ellaurie, a man who lives approximately 20 meters from a school for Islamic studies, was subjected to the sound of the Call to Prayer emanating from the mosque located within the school’s property. The purpose of this Call to Prayer is to remind people of the Islamic faith to come to the mosque for their five daily prayers.

The main principle of neighbour law with regard to nuisance cases states that even though everyone has the right to the undisturbed use and enjoyment of their own property, this right can be limited. Furthermore, since people in neighbouring properties have the same right, mutual tolerance of reasonable interference can be seen as a civic value. The court then went on to explain that interference would only be unreasonable and thus actionable if it seriously and materially interfered with the complainant’s ordinary comfort and existence.

Fortunately, the court also helped to further define the reasonableness standard by listing several factors that could influence the reasonableness of an interference. Firstly, the seriousness of the interference must be considered along with time and the duration thereof. Furthermore, whether it is possible to easily avoid the harm caused by the interference and lastly the sensitivity of the complainant towards the harm. However, with regard to the complainant’s sensitivity, the court went on to explain that the harm will not be considered unreasonable just because the particular complainant has a special form or extraordinary degree of sensitivity to the specific interference.

Since the interference was due to religious observances being conducted, the court also reiterated that the Constitution provides protection to freely observe and manifest different religious beliefs.

Thus, Mister Ellaurie was not able to prove that the interference of his right to the use and enjoyment of his property rights was unreasonably infringed upon by the Call to Prayer and thus it did not constitute a nuisance.

It is Important to note that nuisance law is a very complicated aspect of private law and should be dealt with on a case-by-case basis. Thus, it would be prudent to consult an attorney should you find yourself in similar circumstances given that in specific instances alternative remedies might be available in lieu of an approach to court for relief.

Article by Johan Potgieter, Candidate Attorney (B.Comm; LLB)

Category: Community

About Alan

The one with a “My Complex” – incurable but fun. Grumpy, Cynical, Wise and Idiotic. I can also be found HERE.

Previous Post:Fun Fact: zulu village 9
Next Post:Fun Fact: IMGP1791.JPG

Building Automation, Prepaid Meters and Home Automation Products.

Stratlec offers everything you need to MEASURE, MANAGE and SAVE Electricity

Shop Online

MyZA News

  • Why trade unions have shifted to the public sector
  • R300,000 Raised as Empact Connect Puts Community Needs in Focus
  • Geely Welcomes Guests to the International Polo Test at Val de Vie Estate
  • SA Rugby Requests Full Hearing for Erasmus
  • Mdaka hails his charges as SAFA President congratulates Bafana and SA U23s – South African Football Association

MyPR News

  • Why Consumer Validation Has Become a Commercial Advantage
  • Product of the Year Awards 2027 Early Bird Entry Deadline Approaches
  • Bata Opens Two New Stores for KZN Shoppers
  • Prominent Artist – LAZ-LOD
  • B2B Expos Hands Buyers One Indexed Supplier Pack After Each Supplier Day

Cape Town News

  • Prominent Artist – LAZ-LOD
  • Offset Printing Online Asks Clients to Read Past the Cover of a Proof
  • Atterbury Explains How Mixed-Use Precincts Enhance the Workplace Experience
  • Geely Welcomes Guests to the International Polo Test at Val de Vie Estate
  • Suspect Caught Before Robbing Business

NMB News

  • Congratulations Hattingh Bornman
  • Copper Theft and Infrastructure Damage – We Are Targeting the Wrong Miscreants
  • Film Festival Inspires Eastern Cape Learners to Explore Careers in Film Industry
  • Garden Route’s Thriving Economy
  • Hankey Female Suspect Arrested With Drugs Worth R130,000

Copyright © 2026 · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Straton Solar