EThekwini Municipality Mayor Councillor Cyril Xaba has maintained that the DA billboard is racist and slanderous.
Mayor Xaba and senior municipal officials approached the court to rule that the postings are defamatory and to order the DA to remove them and that on return for the final interdict, the DA be ordered to publish the apology.
“The DA objected to our court application arguing that the matter is not urgent, the high court lacks jurisdiction to hear the matter and that the interim relief sought is final in effect. They pleaded that the effect of the interim relief is a restraint of political expression during an election. The court was not persuaded by these arguments, and it went to rule against the DA,” said Xaba.
The Mayor welcomes the decision by the Durban High Court to grant an interdict against the Democratic Alliance (DA) regarding their highly defamatory billboard and subsequent viral social media campaign, accusing him and two senior municipal officials of being part of a “water tanker mafia,” suggesting that they are corrupt, dishonest or part of a criminal enterprise.
“The court’s decision to order the removal and interdict the further dissemination of these harmful postings is a significant victory for truth, institutional integrity, and the rule of law,” Mayor Xaba said.
Xaba added that the DA’s campaign, which falsely linked him, City Manager Musa Mbele and Executive Director of Technical Services Ednick Msweli to alleged “water tank mafia”, crossed the boundary of legitimate political criticism and entered the realm of malicious character assassination.
“While we champion the constitutional right to freedom of expression and robust political debate, these rights cannot be used as a shield to fabricate criminal allegations against public officials.
The false narrative peddled by the DA was a deliberate attempt to mislead the public, erode trust in municipal governance, and damage the personal and professional reputations of the city’s leadership without a shred of evidence,” Xaba said.
The court granted the interdict application against the DA and directed them to pay the legal costs – emphasising that the right to freedom of expression is not absolute, but it must be balanced with the applicants’ rights to dignity and reputation.
Although the court accepted that the DA is entitled to criticise the current administration, however, the court felt that it must protect the applicants’ rights against unsubstantiated allegations conveyed by the highly defamatory billboard.
“This interdict sends a clear message that political parties must be held accountable for the integrity of their campaigns.
Resorting to defamatory, falsehood and sensationalist tactics to score cheap political points undermines democratic processes and distracts from the collective efforts needed to address the city’s actual infrastructure challenges,” he said.
Xaba highlighted the fact that the Municipality is operating a fully insourced fleet of 318 water tankers as a sign of its commitment to end its reliance on privately hired water tankers.
Furthermore, he said the leadership of eThekwini Municipality remained fully focused on its mandate of fixing infrastructure, ensuring consistent water supply to all communities, and root out actual corruption through official, lawful channels.
“We thank the legal team for their swift action and welcome the court’s intervention in restoring accountability and protecting the dignity of public office” Xaba said.

Nobel laureate outshines a day of intolerance